Show/hide navigation

Pixel 2 XL vs iPhone 8 Plus: The biggest Android and iOS flagship phones do battle

We pit Google’s mighty 6-inch Pixel 2 XL against the 5.5-inch iPhone 8 Plus, to see which of these massive flagship mobiles boasts the most premium specs, sharpest screen, best performance and most capable camera.

If you like your smartphone on the big side, this is the comparison review for you.

Google has just released the new Pixel 2 XL here in the UK, a super-sized 6-inch handset that towers over the standard Pixel 2 phone. This beastly blower sports the latest (and greatest) Android Oreo OS as well as updated camera tech, to capture even better results than last year’s excellent shooter.

However, if you’re not already loyal to Google’s Android ecosystem, you might also be enticed by Apple’s all-new iPhone 8 Plus instead. This 5.5-inch mobile is Apple’s biggest handset rbehind the upcoming iPhone X, packing the powerful A11 Bionic chipset for sterling performance, as well as the super-smart iOS 11 and a nifty dual lens camera.

Not only are these handsets massive, they also have the uncanny ability to drain your wallet. Both the iPhone 8 Plus and the Pixel 2 XL start at £799, making them two of the most expensive blowers in 2017.

So what’s the difference between these Apple and Google mobiles and which might be better suited to your particular needs? Here’s our in-depth comparison, and check out our Pixel 2 XL vs iPhone X comparison to see how the new Google handset compares with Apple's special edition smartphone.

Pixel 2 XL vs iPhone 8 Plus: Specs

Phone iPhone 8 Plus Google Pixel 2 XL
Screen size 5.5-inches 6-inches
Screen resolution 1920x1080 2880x1440
Fingerprint sensor? Yes Yes
Water resistant? Yes Yes
OS iOS 11 Android Oreo 8.0
Processor Apple A11 Bionic Snapdragon 835
Memory 3GB 4GB
Storage 64/128GB 64/128GB
Battery 2690mAh 3520mAh
Rear camera 12MP+12MP 12.2MP
Front camera 7MP 8MP

Pixel XL 2 vs iPhone 8 Plus: Design

As these handsets are the biggest devices offered by both Google and Apple, they’re unsurprisingly not too easy to operate one-handed. They’re not only beefy but quite heavy too, which you’ll notice the instant you pick one up.

Still, even though the Pixel phone rocks a bigger screen, it’s about the same size as the iPhone. That’s because the bezels surrounding the screen are pleasingly slender - helped by a fingerprint sensor that’s mounted on the rear instead of beneath the display.

The Pixel 2 XL is constructed mainly from metal, with a glass strip running across the top of the back edge to give it that distinguishable Pixel design. It certainly looks slick and feels hardy too. By comparison, Apple’s latest Plus-sized iPhone now sports mainly glass surfacing, with a glossy rear replacing the matte metal finish of old. This is also impressively durable, all things considered, while hiding fingerprints and other marks well.

Both of these phones are also fully water resistant, so you can dunk them in liquid with no ill effects.

Pixel 2 XL vs iPhone 8 Plus: Screen and media

Although both of these handsets serve up a spacious screen that’s great for watching movies and shows on the go, they’re also quite different when it comes to image reproduction.

Apple has packed a 5.5-inch IPS Retina screen onto the iPhone 8 Plus, which specialises in natural colour reproduction. Meanwhile the Pixel 2 XL uses a 6-inch AMOLED panel (with a stretched 18:9 aspect ratio), although colours somehow aren't any punchier than the iPhone's output. We also don't like the strange tinting, which turns everything blue the moment you tilt the phone.

That said, the Pixel 2 XL does offer superior detail levels, thanks to its Quad HD 2880x1440 resolution. Even though the iPhone 8 Plus’ display is smaller, the Full HD 1920x1080 resolution means you don’t get as much detail packed into every frame.

Neither phone offers a 3.5mm jack for connecting wired headphones, although you do get Bluetooth 5 support so you can stream your audio to one or two speakers or ‘phones at the same time.

Pixel 2 XL vs iPhone 8 Plus: Features and OS

When it comes to the actual software side, these phones are completely different - although they offer many similar features.

The Pixel 2 XL of course uses Google’s Android Oreo OS, which offers a little more customisation than the iPhone 8 Plus’ iOS 11. Both phones offer solid resource management, including battery saver modes and the ability to cull a specific app’s permissions and activities. You also get a cloud solution for backing up and sharing your files, a voice assistant for hands-free operation and so on.

Check out our complete guide to iOS 11 and in-depth Android Oreo feature for all you need to know.

Want to carry around lots of photos, movies and apps? These handsets are evenly matched when it comes to storage, serving up 64GB of space as standard. You can also boost up to 128GB with the Pixel, or 256GB with the iPhone 8 Plus. If you’re hoping to expand though, you’re out of luck; neither of these flagship phones offer microSD expandability.

Interested in VR? Google’s Daydream VR platform is supported by the Pixel, while Apple is yet to offer dedicated virtual reality on its iPhones. Although you do now get support for AR experiences. The Pixel also offers the new Active Edge pressure sensor for quickly accessing Google Assistant, while the iPhone has 3D Touch for accessing specific app features in a flash.

Pixel 2 XL vs iPhone 8 Plus: Performance and battery

If you want the best performance in a smartphone right now, the Pixel XL 2 and iPhone 8 Plus certainly deliver.

In the Google phone you’ll find Qualcomm’s latest Snapdragon 835 chipset, backed by 4GB of RAM. That’s easily strong enough to blast through the latest games with a perfect frame rate and shouldn’t show any signs of slowdown for quite some time.

You’ll get the same super-reliable performance from the iPhone 8 Plus, with its A11 ‘Bionic’ platform of Apple’s own design. This hexa-core chipset is built for multitasking, with Metal 2 support for great-looking mobile games.

So what about battery life? Well, the iPhone 8 Plus offers well over a day of heavy use per charge, including media streaming, gaming and plenty of camera use. We got the same result from the Pixel 2 XL, thanks to its even larger cell.

The iPhone 8 Plus now offers wireless charging, a first for Apple’s mobile devices. This handset uses the Qi standard to charge up cable-free, so you can power it back up at the likes of Starbucks stores, and wherever else offers these pads to customers. That's something you don't get with Google's blower.

Pixel 2 XL vs iPhone 8 Plus: Cameras

These handsets offer a very different camera experience too, although you’ll get a very capable portable snapper in either case.

The iPhone 8 Plus rocks a dual lens camera with a wide-angle and telephoto lens on offer. These are swapped between automatically depending on the kind of shot you’re trying to get, while they can also combine for the Portrait mode to add a bokeh-style background blur to your photos.

Snaps are packed with detail while you can shoot up to 4K resolution video at 60 frames-per-second, for a supremely natural finish. Check out our iPhone 8 Plus camera review for samples and more.

Google’s Pixel 2 XL rocks a single 12-megapixel lens, which is f/1.8 aperture like the iPhone's standard wide-angle snapper. This can capture great high contrast shots thanks to the smart HDR+ mode, as well as Portrait mode photos just like the iPhone 8 Plus, despite using a single lens. This is thanks to a combination of machine learning and the Dual Pixel Sensor tech packed inside. In fact, because a lot of it is down to software smarts, you can even shoot Portrait snaps with the selfie cam. You can't do that with the iPhone.

While 4K video tops out at 30 frames-per-second, you do get a combo of OIS and EIS to smooth out any footage while moving and shooting. The results are therefore less shaky, although we also noticed some audio issues when shooting outside in winds.

Check out our full Pixel 2 XL camera review for all you need to know.

Interested in buying the iPhone 8 or 8 Plus? O2 is offering Apple's latest smartphone and its super-sized sibling right now on contract in the UK. Find out more about O2's iPhone 8 plans here and iPhone 8 Plus plans here.

You should also read

Join the conversation

Back to top ↑